I think we are getting confused on this issue a bit.
My other reply was not in the correct context.
(Another one of my brain farts.)
>The Nokia commonly reports no service in one bar areas..
That was the context I intended my response for.
That is the point that the phone can no longer get a reliable
copy of the control signal. ("No service" message)
Some will lose track of it at one or two bars, while others
can monitor it at less than one bar of signal strength.
Not because one can hear it better than the other,
but because they show a different signal strength in bars
at the same db levels.
> then my M0torola v66 I took back was...The Nokia needs 1 bar to think
> about making a call, two to suceed....
That is a completely different context that I failed to address.
A phone may be able to keep track of the control signal
but when the phone tries to make contact with the tower,
the tower can't hear the phone.
That can result from inadequate transmit power,
bad antenna pattern (gain), compromised or bad receiving antenna,
ambient noise, and other acts of god.
The phone can hear the tower, but can't talk to it.
If someone calls you, then the phone knows
that someone is calling, but it can't complete the call,
because it can't make contact with the tower,
(the tower can't hear the phone)
so the phone records it as a failed call, even
though it can hear the tower and knows who is calling.