Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
General TopicsGSMBluetooth
Providers
AlltelATT WirelessCingularFidoNextelSprint PCST-MobileVerizon
Manufacturers
EricssonNokiaMotorola
Country Specific
Australian GroupUK Group
Related Topics
PocketPCPalmMore Topics ...

Cellular Phone Forum / Providers / Cingular / June 2005

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

New to Cingular... How to "lock down" a Motorola v180 so you don't get unexpected charges on your bill......

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
none - 07 Jun 2005 06:35 GMT
I'm new to Cingular coming from Sprint.

With my Sprint phone, there were settings in the phone to display
confirmation messages if the service you were going to access would
result in additional charges on your bill.  For example, if you were
going to use the web features or make a call while using analog roaming
off the network.

Are there settings on the v180 to either prevent access to or at least
warn before allowing access to features that would result in additional
charges on your bill?

Part of the problem is I don't know what results in additional charges
and what doesn't.  For example, does accessing "MyMEdia" result in
charges?  What about "Media Net" or "My Account"?  The only way to know
what causes charges is to try to access it and see if I get something on
my bill.

I know that sending or receiving a text message would result in a
charge. I've gone to the Message Center website and tried to prevent any
text messages from being sent to the phone.  Also, any time I see
something that looks like a browser popping up, I immediately cancel out
of it and see some message like "xxxx bytes transferred" which probably
means I got charged for that.

Can anyone share any advice?  All I need this phone to do is dial in and
dial out and voicemail.  No PIM... No games... No IM...  No Text...  No
pictures... No downloads...   Just voice with no extra charges.
PC Medic - 07 Jun 2005 11:36 GMT
> I'm new to Cingular coming from Sprint.
>
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
> dial out and voicemail.  No PIM... No games... No IM...  No Text...  No
> pictures... No downloads...   Just voice with no extra charges.

If you have not signed up (as part of your plan) for internet services, you
will not be able to access them.
As far as I know, you only pay for outgoing text messages, incoming are
free.
Ernie - 07 Jun 2005 13:11 GMT
>As far as I know, you only pay for outgoing text messages, incoming are
>free.

Hum, I get charged for 10 cents per message for all
messages, incoming and outgoing.
PC Medic - 09 Jun 2005 11:32 GMT
>>As far as I know, you only pay for outgoing text messages, incoming are
>>free.
>
> Hum, I get charged for 10 cents per message for all
> messages, incoming and outgoing.

I am only charged for outgoing and have confirmed with Billing that is the
case.
perhaps it varies by plan but it was not presented that way to me.
Joseph - 09 Jun 2005 16:07 GMT
>>>As far as I know, you only pay for outgoing text messages, incoming are
>>>free.
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>case.
>perhaps it varies by plan but it was not presented that way to me.

It also matters if you're a native cingular customer or are a "blue"
customer (i.e. acquired in the cingular buyout of AT&T Wireless.)  If
you're in the latter category ATTWS never charged for incoming SMS
while cingular did.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
         
John S. - 07 Jun 2005 15:54 GMT
> As far as I know, you only pay for outgoing text messages, incoming are
> free.

This used to be true. Cingular now charges for incoming and outgoing. If you
use a lot of TXT messages, then it would behoove you to look into a plan for
adding these to your current plan. 10¢ a message is a bit extreme - and they
do NOT come out of your minute pool.
PC Medic - 09 Jun 2005 11:33 GMT
>> As far as I know, you only pay for outgoing text messages, incoming are
>> free.
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> plan for adding these to your current plan. 10¢ a message is a bit
> extreme - and they do NOT come out of your minute pool.
Just got my latest bill two days ago and incoming text messages show .00 for
charge, outgoing .10
Joseph - 07 Jun 2005 16:33 GMT
>As far as I know, you only pay for outgoing text messages, incoming are
>free.

If you're a cingular blue (former AT&T Wireless) yes.  If you're
cingular you pay for both incoming and outgoing messages.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
         
PC Medic - 09 Jun 2005 11:34 GMT
>>As far as I know, you only pay for outgoing text messages, incoming are
>>free.
>
> If you're a cingular blue (former AT&T Wireless) yes.  If you're
> cingular you pay for both incoming and outgoing messages.

Ahh that's it then, I am former Suncom/ATT customer.
Gary - 07 Jun 2005 11:42 GMT
I believe that sending Media messages to your phone does incur a charge.
When I first got my V180 I was able to find (somewhere) what items would be
charged for and how much they would be. I send myself a few pictures and
such as experiments and used one for my background (screensaver) on the
phone.

ANYWAY, I find that web-browsing on a phone is next to useless for me so I
called Cingular and had them disable that service ON MY ACCONT, not on the
phone.
Ernie - 07 Jun 2005 13:13 GMT
>I believe that sending Media messages to your phone does incur a charge.
>When I first got my V180 I was able to find (somewhere) what items would be
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>called Cingular and had them disable that service ON MY ACCONT, not on the
>phone.

Same here. I played with web browsing on my phone and
also found it useless.

And, after my phone was lost/stolen, I found someone
racked up $100 plus of Direct Billed charges, which
I later found out was downloading ringtones and/or
games.

I had internet access and direct billing on my account
disabled to prevent stuff like this from happening
again.
John S. - 07 Jun 2005 15:56 GMT
> I had internet access and direct billing on my account
> disabled to prevent stuff like this from happening
> again.

Direct billing is not a good option for anything that changes because of
usage or other things. Cellular, Electricity, Phone, etc...... all things
that should never be direct billed.
Ernie - 07 Jun 2005 22:19 GMT
>> I had internet access and direct billing on my account
>> disabled to prevent stuff like this from happening
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>usage or other things. Cellular, Electricity, Phone, etc...... all things
>that should never be direct billed.

True.

But I was referring to "Direct Billing" where
sites charge your Cingular account for downloads
(Games, Ringtones).
(PeteCresswell) - 07 Jun 2005 13:07 GMT
Per none:
> All I need this phone to do is dial in and
>dial out and voicemail.  No PIM... No games... No IM...  No Text...  No
>pictures... No downloads...   Just voice with no extra charges.

I'm on tMobile, but I've got a couple of v180's and the same mindset.

The other poster's suggestion about calling Cingular and asking them to update
your account sounds like the best idea.

But I haven't done that (yet...) either.    

What I did was use the v180's  Settings|Security|Phone Lock|Lock Applications
to lock everything except the basics.   That way, although I can still use them,
I have to supply the phone's password before I can get to them.

What prompted this outlook for me was reading a newspaper account of somebody
who managed to ring up thousands of dollars in text messaging fees on her new
phone without even knowing she was doing anything.
Signature

PeteCresswell

none - 08 Jun 2005 04:52 GMT
> What I did was use the v180's  Settings|Security|Phone Lock|Lock Applications
> to lock everything except the basics.   That way, although I can still use them,
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> who managed to ring up thousands of dollars in text messaging fees on her new
> phone without even knowing she was doing anything.

This newspaper story is exactly what I want to avoid.  I understand the
terms of my contract... basically, every feature is "pay per use" except
for the block of voice minutes I get each month.

What I don't understand is how to map those terms to some of the choices
on the phone so I can know which features I can use without additional
charges and which ones will cost me more money.

Obviously, sending a text message or accessing the web browser results
in a charge to the account so those are easy. But what isn't clear is
when you're using the web browser and when you aren't.  For example, is
"MediaNet" the web browser?  Or is "MEdia Mall" the web browser?  Or do
both use the web browser to access different things?  What about "My
Account"?  Does it use the web browser?  If so, are you really charged
for getting access to your account information or is that given to you
for free since you aren't really accessing the "internet".

Then it looks like I can use any of the built-in ringtones or pictures
without being charged extra.  It's only if I were to select one of the
"Shop Ringtones" or "Shop Graphics", etc. choices that it looks like I
would download something and be charged.  However, it isn't clear to me
if the act of shopping for graphics or ringtones in itself would use the
web browser and would result in charges just to look and see what I
could download.  In other words, even if I didn't download a ringtone,
would I still be charged for the data/web access to see the list of what
is available for download? (In essence, a double-whammy)

So here's the list of what can be locked on the phone.  Does anyone care
to comment on what I should lock to accomplish my goal?

MediaNet     (LOCK - sounds like a web browser)
MEdiaMall    (LOCK - sounds like a web browser)
MyAccount    (Maybe lock... are we charged to view account information?)
MyMEdia      (Don't lock because you can use what is on the phone)
 - sounds    (Don't lock, but don't access "Shop" option)
 - pictures  (Don't lock, but don't access "Shop" option)
 - themes    (Don't lock, but don't access "Shop" option)
 - MotoMixer (Don't lock, but don't access "Shop" option)
AddressBook
Settings
-Tools
--Calculator
--Datebook
--Shortcuts
--AlarmClock
--Chat          (LOCK - would use web)
--DialingServices
---FixedDial
---ServiceDial
--SimApplications
--AIM        (LOCK - would use web)
-Audio
-Network    (LOCK)
-WebAccess    (LOCK)
--WebShortcuts    (LOCK)
--StoredPages    (LOCK)
--History    (LOCK)
--GoToURL    (LOCK)
--BrowserSetup    (LOCK)
--WebSessions    (LOCK)
Earl F. Parrish - 10 Jun 2005 11:52 GMT
>> What I did was use the v180's  Settings|Security|Phone Lock|Lock
>> Applications
[quoted text clipped - 72 lines]
> --BrowserSetup (LOCK)
> --WebSessions (LOCK)

Comments inline.

Signature

Earl F. Parrish

Tiffany - 11 Jun 2005 02:02 GMT
>>> What I did was use the v180's  Settings|Security|Phone Lock|Lock
>>> Applications
[quoted text clipped - 70 lines]
>
> Comments inline.

They must allow for some usage for My Account because I go there to check
minutes and bill amount and have never gotten extra charges on my bill. And
believe me, I check my bill with a fine tooth comb! I have also used AIM
once or twice and only got text charges (which can add up if you don't have
that added to your plan).

I was also at ATT person who had to convert to cingluar but I now get
charged for incoming and outgoing text messages. Anything I can do about
this? I have been having MAJOR issues about texting because I have gotten
repeat texts messages, sometimes continual 3-5 times per one message sent. I
tested this with my daughters OGO too, so I know they were only being sent
once. I called tech support, they said it was a tech issue and are suppose
to be adjusting my account. Of course, I want them to go back a few months
as this has been happening for some time. Anyone else ever have this
problem?

T
Joe - 11 Jun 2005 20:25 GMT
Please do this!

CALL CINGULAR and tell them to TURN OFF all internet and text messaging on
your phone!

I learned this the hard way. When I got my new V180 my 11 year old said he
could put me some cool ringtones in the phone. I said ok gave him the phone
and told him to knock himself out.
   Now it was after 9 at night so I knew we were in the free nights and
weekends part of my time and all he had was the phone and his computer, no
creditcards or anything, so the way I looked at it what harm could be done.
Believe me when I say I had NO IDEA that you could order stuff off the
internet and have it billed to your cell phone. When I got my first bill
there was about $20 in Jamster, DirtyHippo and text messaging charges on my
phone.
   To say the least I was one unhappy camper and to make matters worse
there isn't no getting these charges reversed as they claim they are valid.
At any rate these features have now been banned from my phone and Cingular
swears there will be no more of these charges.
   As far as I am concerned this is one big Scam by Cingular. I can not
imagine how many people have been ripped off the way I have. All phones
should come with these features turned off and to get them turned on should
require a special call to get them turned on where someone explains in
detail what charges you could hit with. I still do not understand why my
phone was set up with things turned on that are not included in my rate
plan.

Joe

> I'm new to Cingular coming from Sprint.
>
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
> dial out and voicemail.  No PIM... No games... No IM...  No Text...  No
> pictures... No downloads...   Just voice with no extra charges.
(PeteCresswell) - 11 Jun 2005 20:38 GMT
Per Joe:
>As far as I am concerned this is one big Scam by Cingular.

It's worse with tMobile: you can't even have the account profile changed to
disallow them.
Signature

PeteCresswell

Joseph - 12 Jun 2005 00:52 GMT
>As far as I am concerned this is one big Scam by Cingular. I can not
>imagine how many people have been ripped off the way I have. All phones
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>phone was set up with things turned on that are not included in my rate
>plan.

Maybe before you or anyone who has access to your phone you should
learn what you might do on your phone to accumulate charges such as
*using* it to make calls, text messaging, etc.  It's not the company's
job to make you aware of what you have on your account.  Ignorance is
no excuse.

- -
         
(PeteCresswell) - 12 Jun 2005 01:00 GMT
Per Joseph:
>It's not the company's
>job to make you aware of what you have on your account.  Ignorance is
>no excuse.

But prospective customer might choose another company if they hear enough
complaints here....-)
Signature

PeteCresswell

Joe - 12 Jun 2005 01:27 GMT
I am confused. I have had cell phones for close to ten years and none
accepted billing for items ordered over the internet. I have also had
internet since a 100MHZ computer was considered fast. I have also ordered
thousands of dollars of stuff over the internet with my credit card and
never once has billing the item to my cell phone been an option.
   How should I have know to inquire about something that I do not even
know is possible? If Cingular would have said when I got the phone, Do you
want Text messaging it will cost you a dime both ways I would have said HELL
NO,Why do you need text messaging it is a phone just call me. If Cingular
would have said do want the ability to change your ringtones for $15 dollars
a month I would have again said HELL NO as the default tone was fine with
me. I thought I was getting Phone service and only Phone service. If I had
been ask if I wanted this garbage I would have never got it but nobody ask.
Why should I have assumed I was getting it when the only thing ever talked
about when I was getting the phone was minutes of phone usage.

Joe

>>As far as I am concerned this is one big Scam by Cingular. I can not
>>imagine how many people have been ripped off the way I have. All phones
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
> - -
PC Medic - 12 Jun 2005 02:05 GMT
>I am confused. I have had cell phones for close to ten years and none
>accepted billing for items ordered over the internet. I have also had
>internet since a 100MHZ computer was considered fast. I have also ordered
>thousands of dollars of stuff over the internet with my credit card and
>never once has billing the item to my cell phone been an option.

Guess you have never ordered ringtones or backgrounds before as that is
standard way of billing them.

>    How should I have know to inquire about something that I do not even
> know is possible? If Cingular would have said when I got the phone, Do you
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> $15 dollars a month I would have again said HELL NO as the default tone
> was fine with me.

Apparently not if you sent the little guy of to the internet to download
more 'cool' ringtones.

>I thought I was getting Phone service and only Phone service.

You are, CELLULAR PHONE SERVICE which tends to include many extras just like
a land line does.

>If I had been ask if I wanted this garbage I would have never got it but
>nobody ask. Why should I have assumed I was getting it when the only thing
>ever talked about when I was getting the phone was minutes of phone usage.

And I am sure you READ and signed the same standard contract everyone else
does (you DID read it right?).
It clearly describes other services and additional costs that may be
incurred for their use.

>>>As far as I am concerned this is one big Scam by Cingular. I can not
>>>imagine how many people have been ripped off the way I have. All phones
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>>
>> - -
Joe - 12 Jun 2005 02:35 GMT
> Apparently not if you sent the little guy of to the internet to download
> more 'cool' ringtones.

No I did not care one way or another. So long as the phone makes some sort
of no abnoctious noise to let me know I am being called I do not care what
that is so I really did not care if the kid changed it to something he
thought was cool.

>>I thought I was getting Phone service and only Phone service.
>
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> It clearly describes other services and additional costs that may be
> incurred for their use.

Have you read your contract? Who does? It is written in fine print that even
most lawyers could not understand. I trusted the people selling me the
service which was a mistake on my part as obviously Cingular is not to be
trusted. I went to Cingular to buy a cell phone and cellular service and
that is all that was ever discussed. I at no time ever ask about internet
service or text messaging and that was never brought up. If Cingular is
going to enable these features at very expensive rates do you not think they
should tell you about it when they are signing you up? Do you not think the
Cingular Rep should have ask me when turning my service on "Do you want text
messaging at a dime per message" "Do you want the ability to buy stuff from
the internet and have it billed to your cell phone"? Neither of these
questions were asked and that is why I feel as if I was scammed. Why is what
I say unreasonable?

Joe

>>>>As far as I am concerned this is one big Scam by Cingular. I can not
>>>>imagine how many people have been ripped off the way I have. All phones
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>>>
>>> - -
PC Medic - 12 Jun 2005 14:50 GMT
>> Apparently not if you sent the little guy of to the internet to download
>> more 'cool' ringtones.
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
>
> Have you read your contract?

Sure did!

> Who does?

Any one with half a brain reads any contract prior to signing it.

> It is written in fine print that even most lawyers could not understand.

I found the language quite clear. Especially the parts that talk about
additional features and how they may incur additional charges.

> I trusted the people selling me the service which was a mistake on my part
> as obviously Cingular is not to be trusted.

And the mistake on their part was assuming you were mature enough to be
making such a decision without parental guardian present.
Face it, this is not a Cingular problem, you did not spend even a moment
from what I can see researching the product/service you were purchasing. Itr
was an impulse buy!

> I went to Cingular to buy a cell phone and cellular service and that is
> all that was ever discussed.

And that is all they sold you. You just took no time to see what the
defiinition of  'Cellular Service' was or to ask questions about your
particular plan.

> I at no time ever ask about internet service or text messaging and that
> was never brought up.

Sure it was, you just (admittadly) did not read the service plan or contract
before signing it.
Maybe when you try to bail on your contract Cingular will post a message
here about Joe and how they thought they could trust him but he bailed on us
and never told us he did not want text messaging service before he signed
the contract he did not read.

> If Cingular is going to enable these features at very expensive rates do
> you not think they should tell you about it when they are signing you up?

If Joe is going to buy a service plan and sign a contract for it, do you not
think he should read it and ask questions first?

> Do you not think the Cingular Rep should have ask me when turning my
> service on "Do you want text messaging at a dime per message" "Do you want
> the ability to buy stuff from the internet and have it billed to your cell
> phone"? Neither of these questions were asked and that is why I feel as if
> I was scammed. Why is what I say unreasonable?

No I do not any more than I expected Cox to warn me when I signed up for
internet service that things purchased over the internet could be charged to
my cell phone, credit card, checking account, etc. Or if I wanted email
service or not. Nor did I expect them to ask me if I wanted long distance or
directory assistance service (both incur additional charges) when I ordered
my land line.

> Joe
>
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
>>>>
>>>> - -
PC Medic - 12 Jun 2005 01:59 GMT
> Please do this!
>
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
>    As far as I am concerned this is one big Scam by Cingular. I can not
> imagine how many people have been ripped off the way I have.

Let me get this straight ...you (or someone you authorized) used a function
of an internet site to download ringtones (that I am sure clearly stated the
charge per ringtone), and you feel you got ripped off. Sorry no sympathy
here.

> All phones should come with these features turned off and to get them
> turned on should require a special call to get them turned on >where
> someone explains in detail what charges you could hit with. I still do not
> understand why my phone was set up with things turned >on that are not
> included in my rate
>plan.

Give me a break! Read your agreement and don't turn your cell phone over to
an 11 year old without knowing what they are up to.
Perhaps all cell phones should come with an IQ test you must pass before it
is activated.

>> I'm new to Cingular coming from Sprint.
>>
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
>> dial out and voicemail.  No PIM... No games... No IM...  No Text...  No
>> pictures... No downloads...   Just voice with no extra charges.
Joe - 12 Jun 2005 02:13 GMT
How am I supposed to know my cell phone number is something that should be
protected like a credit card number. The idea of a phone number is to give
it out to where people can call you. If my kid would have said "Dad give me
your credit card to where I can get this" I would have said no. I have
bought thousands of dollars of stuff over the internet and having it billed
to my cell phone was never an option how should I have known this was even
possible when Cingular never told me?

Joe

>> Please do this!
>>
[quoted text clipped - 63 lines]
>>> dial out and voicemail.  No PIM... No games... No IM...  No Text...  No
>>> pictures... No downloads...   Just voice with no extra charges.
PC Medic - 12 Jun 2005 14:53 GMT
> How am I supposed to know my cell phone number is something that should be
> protected like a credit card number. The idea of a phone number is to give
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>
> Joe

Seems to me you should be upset with the kid, not Cingular.
Any of these ringtone sites I have ever seen make it quite clear that the
'purchase' will be billed to your cell phone bill AND you must make some
sort of acknowlegment that you understand this.

Cingular does not offer NetNanny service (that I am aware of)

>>> Please do this!
>>>
[quoted text clipped - 63 lines]
>>>> and dial out and voicemail.  No PIM... No games... No IM...  No Text...
>>>> No pictures... No downloads...   Just voice with no extra charges.
djk - 12 Jun 2005 22:37 GMT
>  Now it was after 9 at night so I knew we were in the free nights and
> weekends part of my time and all he had was the phone and his computer, no
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> there was about $20 in Jamster, DirtyHippo and text messaging charges on my
> phone.

I can see your point. The web sites or where ever you can do
phone billing purchases should require some type of PIN or
password that is linked to your account. Apparently it is set up
that anyone who knows your number can make purchases? If so,
that is a crime and Cingular is just a partner in it.
PC Medic - 13 Jun 2005 00:21 GMT
>>  Now it was after 9 at night so I knew we were in the free nights and
>> weekends part of my time and all he had was the phone and his computer,
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> that anyone who knows your number can make purchases? If so,
> that is a crime and Cingular is just a partner in it.

No, because after you send it to your phone, you have to have possession of
your phone to accept it.
Not like anyone with your number can just charge things to your phone
djk - 15 Jun 2005 15:09 GMT
> No, because after you send it to your phone, you have to have possession of
> your phone to accept it.
> Not like anyone with your number can just charge things to your phone

so the phone itself downloads the ringtone or whatever? that
would me you would have to have some type of data plan on the
phone, correct? I really don't know how it works, but I would
like to. Thanks for any info.
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.