Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
General TopicsGSMBluetooth
Providers
AlltelATT WirelessCingularFidoNextelSprint PCST-MobileVerizon
Manufacturers
EricssonNokiaMotorola
Country Specific
Australian GroupUK Group
Related Topics
PocketPCPalmMore Topics ...

Cellular Phone Forum / Providers / Fido / September 2003

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

No signal any longer... :-(

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
oblivious - 19 Sep 2003 01:56 GMT
Hi, I moved to a different area in Markham and my 3390's signal is now
zilch indoors.  I barely get 1 or 2 bars and that's only for brief
moments in the day.  Their "solution" was that I should try a newer
model phone.  Can I go to any store and buy a GSM phone and put my SIM
card in it?  I don't want to buy a phone from Fido cuz of their
prices.

Many thanks!
Steve Punter - 19 Sep 2003 03:33 GMT
Yes you can buy a USED GSM phone cheaper than Fido sells them as NEW, but
you'll either have to make sure it is UNLOCKED when you get it, or you'll
have to have it unlocked. Unlocking will cost between $25 and $50, plus your
time and effort.

The 3390 actually has fairly good RF characteristics, so even if you bought
a phone with the BEST RF POSSIBLE, it is unlikely that it will get service
where your 3390 cannot. If having service at home is deathly important to
you (like you don't have a landline phone there) then you will have to
consider switching to a different provider, or hope that Microcell
Connexions soon puts in the planned site at McCowan & Highway 7 (assuming
you live in the dead zone caused by the lack of that site).
Signature

Steve Punter
http://www.arcx.com/sites

oblivious - 19 Sep 2003 07:35 GMT
Thank you sincerely for your detailed reply.  I am now learning more
than ever before about this entire cell phone technology (and
realizing how shafted I've been by Fido customer service all these
years).

Steve I also read your website with great interest and appreciation
for your knowledge.  I didn't know how clueless I was!

On that note, where do I find websites/stores in Canada or the US that
sell like-new/used GSM phones for very reasonable prices???  Would it
be cheaper to buy US and ship or to just buy local???

For the record I moved to Bur Oak Ave. just northeast of 16th Ave. and
Markham Rd.  It's a developing area with hundreds of houses going up
everywhere.

Fido's customer service's best response is that they don't guarantee
service indoors, which, while is fair in certain cases (say I have a
chronic fear of being bombed and lived in a 6ft thick concrete bunker
under my house and want my cellphone to work still), I imagine that
not being able to receive a signal from the upstairs level of a house
that is well within their coverage area would be an exception rather
than the norm, as their customer service agents seem to imply by
hiding behind their disclaimers about "indoor" reception.

I am very suspicious that whatever tower is servicing my area is
barely cutting it.  I stand in the front doorway and I get a signal.
I shut the door and it's gone.

> Yes you can buy a USED GSM phone cheaper than Fido sells them as NEW, but
> you'll either have to make sure it is UNLOCKED when you get it, or you'll
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> Connexions soon puts in the planned site at McCowan & Highway 7 (assuming
> you live in the dead zone caused by the lack of that site).
Ototin - 19 Sep 2003 13:03 GMT
>I am very suspicious that whatever tower is servicing my area is
>barely cutting it.  I stand in the front doorway and I get a signal.
>I shut the door and it's gone.

Try the following experiment.
With the door open stand just inside the threshold. Check for signal
level. Now check the signal level by the window(s) located on the same
wall as the door.
oblivious - 19 Sep 2003 20:23 GMT
Hey Ototin, I tried your suggestion and here's what happens:

I stand in the threshold of the open doorway and face southwest and
the signal bars shoot up.  I move laterally to the adjacent inside
windows, still pointing southwest and I promptly lose one or two bars
(it kinda hovers back and forth).  I'd say the signal gets cut in half
or by a third at best.  I've tried that while keeping the phone on and
also from a power on but the signal strength never reaches full while
inside the windows.  This isn't bulletproof glass, just standard
double paned insulated.  In fact, if I then put my hand over the
3390's built in antenna, the signal disappears completely.  That to me
is NOT a good indication of a reliable signal/service and Fido is
going to have to answer for that.  I'm paying for the bloody thing.

After now hearing that there is a "missing link" at McCowan/Hwy 7, I
am more inclined to believe that whatever cell tower is actually
servicing my area is way too far out to accommodate the area
adequately.

> >I am very suspicious that whatever tower is servicing my area is
> >barely cutting it.  I stand in the front doorway and I get a signal.
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> level. Now check the signal level by the window(s) located on the same
> wall as the door.
Rick Scott - 20 Sep 2003 01:57 GMT
(oblivious <jwestmaas@hotmail.com> uttered:)
> I stand in the threshold of the open doorway and face southwest and
> the signal bars shoot up.  I move laterally to the adjacent inside
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> also from a power on but the signal strength never reaches full while
> inside the windows.

Does the signal reach full when you're standing outside or in the
doorway?  I'm no expert, but if you're getting a full signal outside,
and almost nothing inside, it sounds like you live in a wrought-iron
house.

> This isn't bulletproof glass, just standard double paned insulated.
> In fact, if I then put my hand over the 3390's built in antenna, the
> signal disappears completely.  That to me is NOT a good indication
> of a reliable signal/service and Fido is going to have to answer for
> that.  

Again, I'm no expert, but AFAIK putting your hand over an internal
antenna will really mash the signal, even when you're in an area where
it's strong.  

> After now hearing that there is a "missing link" at McCowan/Hwy 7, I
> am more inclined to believe that whatever cell tower is actually
> servicing my area is way too far out to accommodate the area
> adequately.

If you haven't already, have a look at Steve's excellent site
and see for yourself how close Microcell's towers are:

http://www.arcx.com/sites/Microcell-East.htm

Rick
Signature

key CF8F8A75 / print C5C1 F87D 5056 D2C0 D5CE  D58F 970F 04D1 CF8F 8A75
To speak much is one thing; to speak well, another.
    :Sophocles

Steve Punter - 19 Sep 2003 16:10 GMT
>On that note, where do I find websites/stores in Canada
>or the US that sell like-new/used GSM phones for very
>reasonable prices???  Would it be cheaper to buy US and
>ship or to just buy local???

That's not really my area of expertise. Hopefully others will see your
message and provide you with some worthwhile answers. Sorry.

>Fido's customer service's best response is that they don't guarantee
>service indoors, which, while is fair in certain cases (say I have a
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>than the norm, as their customer service agents seem to imply by
>hiding behind their disclaimers about "indoor" reception.

Stock customer service answers aside, the bottom line is that NO cellular
provider can guarantee signals will be strong enough in 100% of the places
to provide usable service inside a structure (even the second floor of a
wood-framed house). Site proximity is ALWAYS your friend, and in the case of
16th & Markham Road the closest sites are Rogers/Telus PCS/Telus Mike.

>I am very suspicious that whatever tower is servicing my area is
>barely cutting it.  I stand in the front doorway and I get a signal.
>I shut the door and it's gone.

If the signal is weak, what you just described is very likely, especially if
you have a front door containing a metal core, or metal skin (and many do).
The Fido site serving your area is likely the one on Markham Road down by
Highway 7, or possibly the one at Major MacKenzie & Kennedy.
Signature

Steve Punter
http://www.arcx.com/sites

JFmezei - 19 Sep 2003 16:33 GMT
> Fido's customer service's best response is that they don't guarantee
> service indoors, which, while is fair in certain cases

Actually, it is fair in all cases.  The mobile telcos have little tructs that
can roam a region's street to monitor signal strength, but they don't crash
into home to verify signal strength inside a home.

If you look at the USA Verizon commercials, the "can you hear me now?" guy is
always outdoors :-)

Also, because homes vary in the way they are built, Fido might have service
inside home #1 but not inside the home #2 that is next door.

Having said this, I would think that Microcell has enough experience by now to
be able to know that if you do not have a certain signal strength outdoors,
then you won't have service indoors.

Having said this, I think it is lame for sa telco to just say "we don't
garantee service indoors". If you want a mobile phone to be reliable, you need
to have the expectation that your phone will work indoors and outdoors.

The one technology when it really only works outdoors is satelite phones since
you need line of sight to a satellite. But for mobile phones, it is just a
question of having the cells close enough so that the whole area has a signal
that is strong enough to penetrate into homes.
Nick Qapmoc - 19 Sep 2003 18:10 GMT
Just how did FIDO's customer "shaft" you all these years??

> Thank you sincerely for your detailed reply.  I am now learning more
> than ever before about this entire cell phone technology (and
[quoted text clipped - 37 lines]
> > Connexions soon puts in the planned site at McCowan & Highway 7 (assuming
> > you live in the dead zone caused by the lack of that site).
RRoSaLeS - 19 Sep 2003 19:53 GMT
hi,

you might want to try HOFO... it's at www.howardforums.com... there is
a forum there that is dedicated in BST of GSM phones...

hth

> Thank you sincerely for your detailed reply.  I am now learning more
> than ever before about this entire cell phone technology (and
[quoted text clipped - 37 lines]
> > Connexions soon puts in the planned site at McCowan & Highway 7 (assuming
> > you live in the dead zone caused by the lack of that site).
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.