Hi all.
A question for you good guys & gals.
I'm thoroughly bored with my existing mobile.
I'd really like a P900, but I don't feel I'll get my moneys worth out of it.
Originally, I wanted it to read ebooks, listen to MP3s, and as a PIM. Since
having had a baby however, the need for the first ones has diminished
greatly, so I'm basically paying £500 (over the first year, one way or
another) for some shiny kit. My mobile use is pretty low (less than
£10/month, most calls on peak to land line & orange) , so weighing up a
cheap phone & expensive contract or a sim-free phone I'm still looking at ~
£500 over the 1st year, which I'd rather put towards a car.
I was seriously considering a Nokia 3510i, but I've seen an awful lot of
reviews which say the phone stops working, the screen's crap, the speaker
stops working etc. It _looks_ highly unreliable. Is the "Lower" res screen
_really_ that bad?
I've seen this for £60 upwards on Orange PAYG (register the sim, and swap my
OVP Virgin & the new PAYG sim & I'm sorted)
The next sort of price band is the ~£200 band. I can get a colour Nokia with
the better res screen (128*128 rather than 96*whateveritis) for this much,
but I can also get a P800 (which seems to be 95% P900) for the same price.
My "wants" are...
* Cheap
* PAYG (pref Orange) or SIM free
* Reliable
* Colour screen (higher res the better)
* Poly ringtones
* The ability to upload details, images, tones via a PC
* GPRS
* Bluetooth (for hands free)
* Email (POP3 would be nice, but "Orange email" would do.
* WWW would be nice, WAP would do.
* Tri band would be nice, but not vital.
* IRDA would be nice, but not vital.
* Camera would be nice, but not vital.
I've always been a bit wary of brands like LG, having seen the crud they
release in other electronic markets.
I'm open to recommendations from other manufacturers.
A thousand thanks,
Pete.

Signature
NOTE! Email address is spamtrapped. Any email will be bounced to you
Remove the news and underscore from my address to reply by mail
hairydog@despammed.com - 31 May 2004 19:28 GMT
>I was seriously considering a Nokia 3510i, but I've seen an awful lot of
>reviews which say the phone stops working, the screen's crap, the speaker
>stops working etc. It _looks_ highly unreliable. Is the "Lower" res screen
>_really_ that bad?
No. I think it is pretty horrible: a not very nice screen, and horrid
keypad, but it works OK, and the battery life is reasonable: nothing
like as good as the 3510, but still OK.
As you've noticed, it is also commendably cheap, but consider a SE
T610 or T630. Superb value for money.

Signature
Iain
the out-of-date hairydog guide to mobile phones
http://www.hairydog.co.uk/cell1.html
Browse now while stocks last!
Lawrence - 31 May 2004 19:30 GMT
<snip>
>My "wants" are...
>
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
>* IRDA would be nice, but not vital.
>* Camera would be nice, but not vital.
Sony Ericcson T610 seems to fit the bill, available on orange payg for ~£120
from places like
http://www.cyren-communications.co.uk
Regards,
L
Chogaire - 31 May 2004 20:48 GMT
* Cheap
* PAYG (pref Orange) or SIM free
* Reliable
* Colour screen (higher res the better)
* Poly ringtones
* The ability to upload details, images, tones via a PC
* GPRS
* Bluetooth (for hands free)
* Email (POP3 would be nice, but "Orange email" would do.
* WWW would be nice, WAP would do.
* Tri band would be nice, but not vital.
* IRDA would be nice, but not vital.
* Camera would be nice, but not vital.
When you find a *cheap* phone that has all of the above......will you let me
know? I'll have two! :-)
I got a Nokia 3200 from the link at £99.99, no POP 3 email client but it has
camera, radio, 16 chord polyphony, IrDA port, GPRS but has no Bluetooth. But
there again, no phone that has all the above is "cheap". If I were you, I'd
get a Sony Eric T610 or T630...or if you can live without Bluetooth and POP
3 (and no internal modem for connecting laptops etc) I'd get a Nokia 3200.
Pete Smith - 31 May 2004 21:43 GMT
> * Cheap
> * PAYG (pref Orange) or SIM free
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
> get a Sony Eric T610 or T630...or if you can live without Bluetooth and POP
> 3 (and no internal modem for connecting laptops etc) I'd get a Nokia 3200.
Thanks for all the feedback so far guys!
I think we have a _definite_ recommendation for a T610 or T630.
Seems to do all I want, nice screen, GPRS, BT, very very shiny.
Thanks again,
Pete.

Signature
NOTE! Email address is spamtrapped. Any email will be bounced to you
Remove the news and underscore from my address to reply by mail
hairydog@despammed.com - 31 May 2004 23:06 GMT
>I think we have a _definite_ recommendation for a T610 or T630.
>
>Seems to do all I want, nice screen, GPRS, BT, very very shiny.
The T630 screen is much brighter

Signature
Iain
the out-of-date hairydog guide to mobile phones
http://www.hairydog.co.uk/cell1.html
Browse now while stocks last!